search = Sue's Recipes

M&M Cookies-XMAS

From the Kitchen of: Aunt Shirl


NOTE: Dec 2015, used *Kitchen Aid mixer (instructions are w/ the mixer)- OK!! (remember don't overbeat)

Using a mixer or by-hand... First, Measure all ingredients...

Re: BROWN SUGAR: remove or break-up any hard chunks and pack sugar down into the measuring cup. Measure just a little less flour, for best texture & flavor. Mix the soda & salt together.

Always add ingredients in the order listed...

     *if using Kitchen Aid Mixer, do not mix until after all ingredients are added to the bowl. Start on Low with short/quick mixing pulses (careful so flour doesn't fly out of bowl). Then mix Low about 30 seconds to 1 minute, scraping the bowl & beater a couple of times.  Otherwise...

      In large bowl, add first 5 ingredients, one at a time, stir very well. Add flour & soda/salt and mix well. Pat dough into 2-4 thick pancake-like portions. Place in tupperware-like container with wax paper between the portions. Cover tightly & let dough rest in refrigerator for about 30 minutes, or may stay in frig for several weeks.

(If dough has been refrigerated for longer than an hour & is hard, place on countertop for 1 hour-ish to come close to room temperature)   Fill Red measuring tablespoon with dough.  Place loosely rounded dough onto cookie tray, almost 2 inches apart. (dough spreads out a little while baking). Then deco with 3 M&M's per cookie.

Bake at 375 degrees 9 to 9.5 min, til lightly brown, but still soft. DON'T OPEN OVEN, until ready to remove the cookies! Cool 1 minute in tray and then move to cookie rack to cool completely.

**If dough was refrigerated for an hour or more, bring close to room temp before prepping to bake.


Last Modified: December 26, 2023